Cheddar's-Style New Orleans Pasta

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

There’s something magical about bringing a restaurant favorite to your own kitchen. This Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta is the kind of recipe that transforms an ordinary weeknight into a spicy, creamy celebration—New Orleans style. Imagine a big, bubbling pan where tender chicken, smoky sausage, and plump shrimp mingle in a rich, Creole-spiced Alfredo sauce, tossed with heaps of penne. The aroma alone will make everyone flock to the kitchen.

With just the right mix of heat and creaminess, this dish is comforting, bold, and very, very craveable. It’s surprisingly easy, too—no hard-to-find ingredients or fussy techniques. Grab a large skillet, a pot of boiling pasta, and a stretch of 45 cozy minutes: you’re on your way to serious comfort food bliss.

Table of Contents

Big flavors require serious kit—here’s what you need

Setting yourself up for this richly layered pasta means breaking out some trustworthy tools. Here’s what you’ll need to create every creamy, spicy, savory bite:

Large pot – For boiling up perfect penne pasta and building that luscious Alfredo sauce.
Large skillet – The go-to for browning chicken, sautéing sausage, and getting the shrimp just right.
Cutting board and knife – For slicing sausage, chicken, onion, and bell pepper into just the right size bits.
Stirring spoon or spatula – To keep your sauce smooth and meats beautifully bronzed.
Measuring spoons and cups – Precision will help your flavors shine, so you don’t end up too salty or bland.
Colander – For draining your pasta just before it meets the sauce.

Lean into your favorite kit, but keep it simple. A few heavy-duty basics get the job done.

Ingredients that make Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta sing

chicken breast (cut into bite-sized pieces) – The foundation for juicy, savory bites that soak up all the flavor.
Italian dressing – Adds layers of tang and tenderizes the chicken in no time.
Penne pasta – Catches every drop of creamy, spicy sauce in its ridges and tubes.
Butter – Creates a golden, plush base for your sauce.
All-purpose flour – Thickens everything up, forming a rich, glossy roux.
Heavy cream – Brings full-bodied, luxuriously smooth texture to the Alfredo.
Shredded parmesan cheese – Delivers deep umami and a salty finish.
Shredded mozzarella – For stretchiness and that irresistible melty factor.
Salsa – Sneaks in tang, spice, and a jolt of color throughout the sauce.
Tony Chachere’s Creole Seasoning – An essential blast of classic, zesty New Orleans flavor.
Smoked sausage (sliced) – Lively smokiness and a delightfully snappy texture.
Shrimp (medium sized, peeled and deveined) – Sweet, briny bites that cook up fast and juicy.
Green bell pepper (sliced) – Earthy aroma and bright pops of color.
White onion (sliced) – Lends mellow sweetness as it cooks down in the skillet.

See the recipe card below for the full list of ingredients and measurements.

Every step for Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta perfection

Marinate the chicken by tossing it in Italian dressing. Let the chicken sit for about an hour so it gets super-tender and infused with just the right zing. Discard the marinade once done.
Boil the penne pasta according to the package directions. Drain it just before you’re ready to toss everything together, so it stays springy.
Start the sauce base: In your largest pot, melt the butter over medium heat. Stir in all-purpose flour and cook, whisking constantly, until it smells nutty and turns pale gold—about a minute.
Make it creamy and bold by stirring in the heavy cream, parmesan, mozzarella, and salsa. Keep stirring until smooth; once thickened, let it simmer on low until needed. The sauce should coat your spoon, looking glossy.
Brown the marinated chicken in a hot skillet with a swirl of oil. Cook for about 5–7 minutes, stirring once in a while, until no longer pink and slightly golden. Remove to a plate.
Quick-sear the smoked sausage. Toss the sliced sausage into the same skillet and cook until the edges are sizzling and bronzed. Remove and wipe out any burned bits from the skillet.
Season and sauté the shrimp with a sprinkle of Creole seasoning. Add more oil to the pan and cook the shrimp just until they’re barely pink on both sides. Remove promptly—don’t overcook!
Sauté the veggies: If needed, add more oil, then cook the onion and green bell pepper until soft and fragrant, with just a bit of golden color on the edges.
Combine everything: Gently toss the cooked pasta, all the meats, and the sautéed vegetables into your creamy sauce pot. Stir until everything is velvety, bright, and well coated.
Serve immediately, piling it high in bowls to capture all the creaminess and big New Orleans flavors. Don’t wait—the pasta is perfect right from the pan.

Troubleshooting common pitfalls for this creamy Cajun pasta

Even seasoned cooks sometimes hit a snag with layered, creamy pastas. Here’s how to keep Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta looking and tasting like a knockout every single time:

Sauce too thick or too thin? If your sauce seizes or reduces too much, splash in a bit more cream or a spoonful of warm pasta water until it loosens. If it’s too thin, simmer it a little longer but don’t crank up the heat—gentle is best to avoid burning or separating.
Overcooked shrimp or chicken? Shrimp turn rubbery in minutes; take them out as soon as they’re pink and just barely firm. Chicken dries out if you crowd the pan or use high heat—spread the pieces and let them develop color without charring.
Pasta sticking together? Cook it last if you can, drain well, and toss with a tiny bit of oil if it’s waiting in the colander. It will loosen up once mixed into the creamy sauce.
Curdled or grainy sauce? This usually happens when cream boils hard. Keep your heat moderate and stir gently as cheese melts in, ensuring a silky finish.
Uneven seasoning? Taste, adjust, taste again. The sausage and Creole seasoning are both salty; if you want more heat or zip, add little by little.

I’ve found that letting the components cool slightly before mixing helps every bite stay just right. Don’t rush—layering is key!

Ways to make it your own—pairings, variations, and more

If you’re looking to round out your meal or give this pasta a personal twist, here are some ideas to fit every mood and table:

Pair it up: This rich pasta begs for a crisp, cool salad—think simple greens, lemon vinaigrette, maybe a handful of cherry tomatoes for sweet snap. Warm, buttery garlic bread is nearly a must for sopping up every bit of sauce.
Soup and salad sides: Try a classic Caesar salad, a bright cucumber-tomato mix, or a steaming bowl of vegetable soup as a starter.
Beverage matchups: A chilled glass of Sauvignon Blanc or a citrusy, hoppy IPA works beautifully. Sparkling water with lime is fresh and non-alcoholic.

Ready to riff on the original? Here are some favorite tweaks:

Add heat: Up the Creole seasoning or sneak in a pinch of cayenne.
Make it milder: Use a mild salsa and go light on the Creole spice—a must for little ones or the spice-averse.
Lighter swap: Try half-and-half instead of heavy cream for a slightly leaner sauce, but simmer gently to avoid curdling.
Seafood spin: Leave out the chicken and sausage and double the shrimp—or toss in lump crab for a celebration dinner.
Allergy-friendly: Use gluten-free penne and your favorite thickener for the roux if you need to skip regular flour.

This pasta is the ultimate “use what you love” kind of meal—and after a few tries, you’ll discover your own signature twist.

FAQs about Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta

How should I store leftover Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta?

Cool any leftovers quickly and store in an airtight container in the fridge. The pasta and sauce will thicken as they sit, but should stay tasty for up to 3 days. Give everything a gentle stir and a splash of cream or milk when reheating to bring the sauce back to life.

Can I substitute the protein in Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta?

Absolutely! This dish is flexible. You can swap shrimp for extra sausage or chicken, or even go meatless by increasing the bell pepper and onion and adding sautéed mushrooms. Just adjust cooking times so nothing overcooks.

Is Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta freezer-friendly?

Because of the creamy sauce, this pasta is best enjoyed fresh. If you do freeze it, know the sauce may separate slightly. For best results, freeze in small portions, thaw gently, and stir well with a bit of fresh cream or milk after reheating.

One bite and you’re in New Orleans: conclusion

Cheddar’s-Style New Orleans Pasta is the kind of dish that turns any dinner into an occasion, filling your kitchen with the tantalizing aroma of spice, smoke, and creamy cheese. Every forkful pops with contrast—springy penne, velvet sauce, tender meats, and crisp-tender veggies. It’s festive, soulful, and guaranteed to satisfy. Serve it hot and watch the smiles spread around your table—no passport required, just a serious appetite for comfort and flavor.

More Delicious Recipes

Cheesy Ranch Potatoes and Smoked Sausage: This dish features smoky sausage, giving you the same rich flavors and comforting essence found in the New Orleans pasta.
Slow Cooker Chicken Pot Pie: A creamy chicken dish that makes for a hearty meal, similar in comfort and richness to the pasta recipe.
Bang Bang Chicken Rice Bowl: This recipe offers a spicy twist with chicken, reflecting the bold flavors you’ll love in the New Orleans pasta.